Central or departmental compressed air system?

Size and configure compressed air piping for the right fit.

By Hank van Ormer, Air Power USA

1 of 5 < 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 View on one page

In brief:

  • Early on, PVC was used for compressed air piping, and it wasn’t long before it became evident that PVC sometimes shattered when it failed, sending sharp pieces throughout the area.
  • Copper pipe is a common selection for sensitive air systems. It’s very rugged when selected and connected correctly.
  • Air condensate tends to be acidic. In oil-free compressors, it’s usually particularly aggressive without the oil to neutralize it.

Which is better — a classical centralized air system or a departmental compressed air system? Reports suggest that neither system is better. Quite often, the right choice is a combination or variation of both. Here’s why.

A central air system satisfies total air demand for total plant operations. Air provided by one or more compressors is distributed from a central supply point to areas requiring air service. Compressors in such a system are commonly installed in a powerhouse area with other utilities.

In a departmental air system, several air compressors are located at principal points of use throughout the plant. This approach can be used instead of, or in combination with, the central type.

Variation can pay

Each has its advantages and disadvantages. In deciding which is best for your needs, weigh the total benefits gained against the drawbacks that go with the choice. The case for one system over the other isn’t always clear cut. The judicious plant engineer, after weighing the facts and figures, might arrive at a combination of both, or even a variation. Here’s a hypothetical example.

A 50,000-cfm centralized air system has several centrifugal compressors. They’re the most efficient and economical for this size application. However, the units have a 100-psig maximum discharge pressure. The plant requires 2,100 cfm at 150 psig in one department, 24 hours a day. Two options are available.

  • Install a complete air system delivering 2,100 cfm at 150 psig in the department. A complete system such as this will use about 500 hp and cost approximately $150,000 to $175,000 uninstalled.
  • Install a booster compressor to provide the required 2,100 cfm by kicking the 100-psig system pressure to the required 150 psig. A correctly applied, double-acting, single-stage reciprocating booster, requiring only 125 hp, will do the job for about $40,000 to $50,000, uninstalled.

Obviously, this small booster represents tremendous savings. At a utility cost of $0.04/kWh, a savings up to 375 hp can amount to more than $100,000 per year in power savings alone, not including the cost of the 100 psig inlet air. If all or part of the 2,100 cfm of 100-psig air is available from blow off, this might generate significant savings. While this is but one example, there are many situations offering the plant engineer a chance to save on air system installation and operating costs. It takes careful planning and correctly applied knowledge of compressed air, compressed air systems and compressed air equipment.

It’s important to understand the classical approaches to compressed air systems and air compressor selection. You also should be aware of what modern materials, air compressor design and compressed air requirements have done to increase the opportunities for both initial and continuing cost saving.

Filter technology has come so far in recent years that virtually any degree of cleanliness can be reached economically with little or no pressure drop.

To get more work and efficiency out of compressors, many manufacturers of air production machinery and tools now require higher pressure and higher quality air that’s dryer and cleaner than the standard aftercooler untreated air. Air compressor manufacturers responded with a variety of machine designs that allow the system engineer many options.

High-performance, oil-cooled rotary compressors, both vane and screw types available as fully packaged air systems offer nearly complete installation flexibility. These continuous duty units with air-cooled and water-cooled oil coolers are relatively small and very quiet. They can be used for departmental air and compromise nothing in durability. Single-stage, oil-cooled rotaries offer full load pressures to 175 psig, and two-stage units can go even higher.

Rotary units, lobe or screw type, non-lube, air or water-cooled, two-stage compressors provide good efficiency and continuous duty from 50 hp to 600 hp. They’re usually higher in initial cost and somewhat less efficient than the air-cooled two-stage lubricant-cooled rotaries. Single and two-stage double-acting reciprocating, water-cooled units are the most expensive to buy and install, but they’re also often the most efficient. Therefore, they have the lowest power cost compared with other types of similar sizes.

Modern air compressor design produced heavy-duty, short-stroke, higher-rpm, smooth-running, lightweight, single-acting reciprocating, air- and water-cooled units that require no special foundation. They’re quite suitable for providing high pressure air for localized or departmental applications. Heavy-duty units generally are available from 5 hp to 75 hp, 20 cfm to 170 cfm and 150 psig to 5,000 psig. They often serve as departmental air to supply a special process requirement.

The need for air filters that deliver instrument-quality, oil-free air continues to increase. Filter technology has come so far in recent years that virtually any degree of cleanliness can be reached economically with reasonabe or no pressure drop.

After you determine what kind of system best suits your plant, you must address other considerations.

  • What kind of air distribution system?
  • What will be the key air supplier?
  • Is the air lubricated or non-lubricated?
  • Should the compressed air be dried?
  • If so, then how dry, how clean and how much hydrocarbon is acceptable?
1 of 5 < 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 View on one page
Show Comments
Hide Comments

Join the discussion

We welcome your thoughtful comments.
All comments will display your user name.

Want to participate in the discussion?

Register for free

Log in for complete access.

Comments

No one has commented on this page yet.

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments