6 strategies to align operations and maintenance teams around reliability
Key Highlights
- Operations decides equipment availability and repair timing, informed by maintenance’s technical assessment.
- Maintenance advises on failure causes, repair scope, risks, resources and estimated work duration.
- Operators should monitor equipment and report abnormalities, not become substitutes for maintenance technicians.
- Maintenance management owns maintenance strategies, preventive maintenance decisions and work requirements.
- Both departments should honor commitments, prepare for outages and be accountable.
When everyone is responsible for equipment reliability, ultimately, no one is. It can become difficult to determine who is accountable for decisions. Operators are expected to own their equipment, maintenance teams are responsible for keeping it running, and management wants both departments working together. But what happens when those responsibilities overlap?
In a recent episode of Ask a Plant Manager, my co-host Joe Kuhn, retired plant manager, reliability consultant and longtime Plant Services columnist, discussed the sometimes-complicated relationship between operations and maintenance. His advice centers on a simple idea that operations owns reliability, and maintenance owns the technical work and maintenance functions. It can be complicated in execution, but we break down the steps.
Kuhn calls the two groups: deciders and advisors. Operations makes decisions about equipment availability and when maintenance work can happen. Maintenance provides the technical expertise needed to diagnose problems, recommend repairs and estimate the resources and time required.
Here are six ways plant leaders can establish clearer ownership and improve collaboration between the two departments. This article is based on our monthly podcast episodes. You can also watch the full episode below on YouTube.
1. Make operations accountable for reliability decisions
Kuhn often uses a car analogy to explain why operations should own reliability.
When a car starts making unusual noises or is running hot, the owner is responsible for taking it to a repair shop. The mechanic diagnoses the problem and estimates the time and cost. But the owner ultimately decides which repairs to authorize and when to have them completed.
The same relationship should exist between operations and maintenance in a plant.
“If everyone owns the problem, nobody owns the problem. Nobody's responsible. Who takes the ball and runs with it?” Kuhn asks.
Maintenance personnel have the technical expertise to understand equipment failures and diagnose problems. Operations, meanwhile, understands production requirements and makes the decisions about when equipment can be taken out of service with recommendations from maintenance.
An operator might decide to address a problem immediately or schedule the repair for the following week. But those decisions should be informed by maintenance's technical assessment.
“That is a major part of reliability, making that decision,” Kuhn says.
He also warns that reliability suffers when the two departments start blaming each other. That creates an us-versus-them culture instead of shared accountability.
"Each one has a different role. Let people do what they are empowered to do," Kuhn says.
2. Treat maintenance as the technical advisor, not the decision-making bottleneck
If operations owns reliability decisions, maintenance needs to understand its role as the technical advisor.
“Maintenance naturally, they're the most skilled people on diagnosing the problem. They know how the equipment would fail. They know an estimate of how long it's going to take to fix something. It's usually not the first time something's failed, right?” Kuhn says.
Operations needs that expertise to make informed decisions. Kuhn recommends that maintenance provides the following information to operations:
- What is wrong with the equipment?
- What repairs or adjustments are required?
- How much time will the work take?
- What parts, personnel and resources are needed?
- What are the risks of delaying the repair?
Then, operations can make an informed decision about the timing of the work.
The important distinction is that maintenance should not be expected to make production decisions, just as operations should not be expected to make technical maintenance decisions without consulting the people who understand the equipment.
Kuhn says he has generally found maintenance personnel receptive to operations taking a more active role in reliability. In his experience across 42 plants, he has not seen maintenance teams withdraw from their responsibilities simply because operations became more involved. It helps break the you-vs.-them blame cycle.
“Operations-led really was a big yawn whenever we made that change. It wasn't dramatic at all,” Kuhn says.
3. Don't shift preventive maintenance work to operators
Operators are often the first people to notice changes in equipment performance, unusual sounds, leaks, quality problems or other problem conditions, but Kuhn cautions against turning operator involvement into an excuse to transfer maintenance responsibilities to production.
One example he recalls involved a power plant where operators were asked to monitor sight glasses on large fan motors and gearboxes and top off the oil when necessary.
“It sounded extremely simple. Here’s the oil. Here’s where you put it in,” Kuhn says. Operators could perform the task without extensive training, but the problem was prioritization.
“When you give a task like that to operations, where is it on their daily priority to do?” Kuhn asks.
Operators already had competing responsibilities involving equipment performance, quality, housekeeping and other production issues. Lubrication became another task on an already crowded list, and it frequently fell to the bottom.
By contrast, when a maintenance craftsman is assigned lubrication work, that task is a primary responsibility. The craftsman also understands the importance of using the correct lubricant and quantity and can identify other developing problems.
At another textile facility with approximately 100 sewing machines, operators were supposedly responsible for lubricating the machines every shift. When Kuhn asked the operators about the task, every one of them believed the responsibility had been discontinued. Management, however, thought the work was still being completed.
The lesson is that assigning a task does not guarantee that it will happen. “You’ve got to have an auditing process,” Kuhn says.
4. Make operators the first line of equipment monitoring
Rather than expecting operators to take on preventive maintenance tasks, Kuhn sees them contributing to basic equipment care and early problem detection. Operators know how equipment is supposed to run. They can recognize when a machine sounds different or when production quality starts to deteriorate.
They can also help maintain clean equipment and work areas, making it easier to identify leaks, damage and other abnormal conditions.
Kuhn describes operators as the eyes, ears and nose of maintenance technicians. Their responsibility is to recognize when something isn't right and communicate that information to maintenance. The maintenance team can then investigate and diagnose the problem.
This also requires a system for reporting equipment conditions. Operators should have a straightforward way to communicate problems and observations, rather than relying on informal conversations or waiting for maintenance personnel to notice something themselves.
The goal is to make operators active participants in reliability without expecting them to become substitute maintenance technicians. “Be extremely careful with giving a maintenance PM-type task to operations. I've only had bad results from that,” Kuhn says.
5. Keep maintenance decisions under maintenance management
Although operations owns reliability, that doesn't mean operators should control every maintenance decision. Kuhn says the maintenance manager should ultimately own maintenance functions, including decisions about preventive maintenance, work requirements, resources and maintenance strategies.
Those decisions should incorporate input from craftspeople, engineers and technicians who understand the equipment and perform the work.
For example, consider a hydraulic system that receives a monthly preventive maintenance inspection. The inspection takes two hours and includes checking several equipment conditions. Over time, the plant introduces oil analysis and vibration monitoring to provide better information about the system's condition.
Maintenance management might decide to replace the monthly inspection with condition monitoring and reduce the frequency of physical inspections to once every six months.
The same applies when changing PM frequencies, adjusting labor requirements or eliminating time-based maintenance activities in favor of predictive maintenance technologies. Management needs to understand the capabilities and limitations of the technology, explain the reasoning behind changes and evaluate whether the new strategy is producing the expected results.
“Those decisions always come from management with an ear toward the craftspeople that are doing the job, because there's risk involved,” Kuhn says.
6. Hold both departments accountable for their responsibilities
Before trying to improve collaboration between operations and maintenance, Kuhn recommends that each department first take responsibility for the things it controls. “Both of those camps need to get their house in order first,” Kuhn says.
For maintenance, that starts with precision work and accurate job estimates.
If a crew is scheduled to perform an eight-hour preventive maintenance job, the work should be completed correctly within the scheduled window.
Maintenance should not routinely perform incomplete repairs that require repeated work to get equipment back to the proper condition.
Operations has responsibilities, too.
If production agrees to turn over equipment from 7 a.m. to 3 p.m., that means maintenance gets the full eight hours. Equipment should be available on time, properly prepared and in the agreed-upon condition.
Likewise, operations should not expect maintenance to return equipment early simply because production wants it back before the scheduled completion time.
Both departments need to respect the commitments they make to each other.
Kuhn also emphasizes that maintenance crews need to be ready when equipment becomes available. If an outage starts at 7 a.m., technicians should be there at 7 a.m., with parts and tools staged ahead of time.
Like to an Indianapolis 500 pit crew, Kuhn says. When a race car pulls into the pit, the crew doesn't start figuring out who needs to change the tires or where the fuel is stored. Everyone knows their responsibilities, and the equipment and materials are ready before the car arrives.
Maintenance outages should be coordinated with the same level of preparation. Both departments need to understand what the other group needs to be successful. Maintenance needs reliable equipment access and adequate time to complete work. Operations needs accurate repair estimates and quality workmanship. When everyone understands those roles, reliability becomes a shared objective.
About the Author
Anna TownshendAnna Townshend
head of content
Anna Townshend is the chief editor and head of content for Plant Services. She has been a journalist and editor for more than 20 years and joined Plant Services and Control Design as managing editor in June 2020. Previously, for more than 10 years, she was the chief editor of Marina Dock Age and International Dredging Review. In addition to writing and editing thousands of articles in her career, she has been an active speaker on industry panels and presentations, as well as host for Great Question: A Manufacturing Podcast. Email her at [email protected].


