Is it maintenance or reliability?

April 8, 2009

The continual debates and semantical posturing over the difference between maintenance and reliability engineering is one of the most astoundingly ridiculous debates to emerge in physical asset management in the last 10 years. 

Some people feel compelled to cut and paste role descriptions when we talk about this stuff, but it can be defined quite simply. Maintenance Engineering is about efficiency while Reliability Engineering is about effectiveness.

The continual debates and semantical posturing over the difference between maintenance and reliability engineering is one of the most astoundingly ridiculous debates to emerge in physical asset management in the last 10 years. 

Some people feel compelled to cut and paste role descriptions when we talk about this stuff, but it can be defined quite simply. Maintenance Engineering is about efficiency while Reliability Engineering is about effectiveness.

It makes sense, and we do not need to get too complex about it. But the more important point isn't how they are different, but how they are the same!

By focusing on workflows, data capture and time and motion (say) you can become extremely effcient at doing the wrong work!

Likewise, there are more than a few reliability initiaives that have worked out the secret of more effective maintenance, and a better application of time and effort that fail. And why do they fail? Often because they do not consider the implications of how this work is going to be done, and what the overall load/impact variatons will be on staff.

To state it a different way, you cannot focus on doing the right job (reliability engineering) without doing it the right way (maintenance engineering).

They are two sides of the same coin, and creating artificial barriers between them is not what people in our profession should be trying to do. Bariers are created to separate "them" from "us" and to protect the status quo.

And as we all know, there is far too much status in the status quo. 

I am voting for tearing down the walls. Make them all Asset Management Engineers and give them all the skills to work across both areas. Divide the work among them based on the supply/demand principles and make sure everyone is very keenly focused on doing the right work, and doing it in the right way.

Amazing that this is even an issue ... 

You can network with other reliability practitioners here, ,and see the latest in reliability jobs here.

Sponsored Recommendations

Enclosure Climate Control: Achieving the Ideal Temperature

March 28, 2024
There are several factors to consider when optimizing the climate inside your electrical enclosure. Download this white paper to learn more.

Find the ideal enclosure cooling solution for your application

March 28, 2024
Use the Climate Control Quickfinder tool to find the ideal climate control solution for your application in just three easy steps.

Smart Cooling Solutions: Reduce Your Energy Consumption with Advanced Technology from Rittal

March 28, 2024
Wall extension cooling units for external or internal mounting in doors and walls using standardized mounting cut-outs. Cooling output 0.3 – 5.8 kW. Also available in energy-efficient...

Arc Flash Prevention: What You Need to Know

March 28, 2024
Download to learn: how an arc flash forms and common causes, safety recommendations to help prevent arc flash exposure (including the use of lockout tagout and energy isolating...