Geothermal heat pumps mine for money

Using a geothermal heat pump is like pulling money out of the ground.

By Robert J. Flaherty

1 of 2 < 1 | 2 View on one page

Heat pump technology has been used in residential and commercial building s for decades. Typical water-source heat pump systems circulate water through cooling towers or boilers to provide a constant-temperature heat source or heat sink for their operation. Geothermal (or ground-source) heat pumps forego the cooling tower/boiler combination and instead use water circulated to and from the earth to provide heat exchange, which results in a more environment-friendly system.

Heat pump operation

Heat pumps operate on a thermodynamic cycle known as vapor-compression refrigeration. In the cooling mode, the heat pump functions as an air conditioner, wherein heat is removed from a space. In the heating mode, refrigerant flow reverses and adds heat to the conditioned space.

The vapor-compression cycle consists of four basic components. The compressor provides energy to circulate the vapor phase refrigerant and to raise its pressure and temperature so it can condense to a high-temperature, and high-pressure liquid as it flows through the second component, the condenser. The condenser is a heat exchanger (a coil) through which high-temperature refrigerant flows and transfers its heat to the heat sink. In a water-source system, the heat sink is the circulating water mentioned above.

The liquid refrigerant flowing from the condenser passes through an expansion device generally known as the thermostatic expansion valve (TXV). The TXV meters the refrigerant flow to match the load and throttles the flow, which reduces the liquid refrigerant’s temperature and pressure while holding its energy content -– its enthalpy – constant. This phenomenon is known as the Joule-Thompson Effect.

The ow-temperature, low-pressure liquid then moves to another heat exchange coil, the evaporator. Here, the liquid refrigerant absorbs heat from the source, which is really the medium to be cooled, the load. As the source cools, it heats the refrigerant enough to cause it to evaporate within the coil, transforming it back to a low-pressure, low-temperature vapor that returns to the compressor to repeat the cycle.

A heat pump includes a fifth component that allows refrigerant to flow in the opposite direction, thereby allowing the condenser to function as an evaporator and the evaporator as a condenser. Avoid confusion when discussing heat pumps by replacing the terms evaporator and condenser with indoor coil (the coil that transfers energy between the refrigerant and the conditioned space) and outdoor coil (the coil that transfers energy between the refrigerant and the environment). Figures 1 and 2 show the refrigerant flow diagram in both operational modes.

Geothermal heat exchange

The heat pump either absorbs heat from or rejects heat to the environment through intermediate devices such as boilers or cooling towers or directly through geothermal exchange.

Many sources of geothermal energy aren’t readily available or have environmental concerns. An available source (to some) might be a lake, pond, river or ocean. Not every site has access to a body of water, and changing the thermal equilibrium in these bodies has the potential to affect the local ecosystem.

Two generally available subsets of geothermal exchange are the ground-coupled heat pump (GCHP) and ground-water heat pump (GWHP). Both systems exchange energy with the earth and have the advantage of being contained entirely within the plant’s boundaries.

In a GCHP system, heat is transferred to and from the ground through a sub-surface network of piping, which acts as a heat exchanger. The goal is to make the temperature of the water circulating within those pipes approach the relatively stable temperature of the soil at depth. In heating-dominated regions, the working fluid is an antifreeze solution because portions of the piping network could be within the frost zone.

Ground-coupled heat pumps

GCHP systems are further classified as vertical or horizontal designs. As the name implies, the vertical GCHP circulates water or antifreeze solution through a series of deeply buried pipes (Figure 3). Designing a vertical system requires a geotechnical consultant or geologist to determine the site’s geology where the pipework will be installed. Given that input, the thermal performance of the rock and soil formations can be estimated to determine the overall underground heat transfer rate. This information, in turn, determines the quantity of vertical pipes (and bores) needed to transfer the energy required to meet the building’s needs. Most installations require multiple bores spaced 15 to 25 ft. apart. The exact number depends on the equivalent full-load hours (EFLH) the system will operate (in heating and cooling) and on the building load.

Horizontal GCHP systems use a network of pipes or coils distributed horizontally, at shallow depth, around a site (Figure 4). Similar to the vertical system, the pipes and coils act as heat exchangers that exchange energy with the ground. The geology close to the surface is generally known, and designing a horizontal system doesn’t involve the same potential pitfalls as a vertical system.

The obvious critical variable with the horizontal GCHP is adequate space on the property to spread out the underground lines. To minimize space requirements, multiple pipes can be placed in a single trench. An alternative method includes spiraling the pipe into a coil. Both approaches require careful backfilling to ensure the pipework is in full contact with the soil. Another consideration is that multiple pipes in a single trench won’t increase the energy exchange rate proportionally. Two pipes in one trench are less than twice as effective as one pipe in a trench. The reason is thermal interference between pipes.

Assuming adequate space is available for the required energy transfer, the horizontal system offers several advantages over the vertical system. These include:

1 of 2 < 1 | 2 View on one page
Show Comments
Hide Comments

Join the discussion

We welcome your thoughtful comments.
All comments will display your user name.

Want to participate in the discussion?

Register for free

Log in for complete access.


No one has commented on this page yet.

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments