CMMS/EAM stress test list grows to 20

By Paul Studebaker

Nov 16, 2004

PeopleSoft’s EnterpriseOne Capital Asset Management version 8.10 and Revere’s Immpower version R6 have now been evaluated by David Berger, P.Eng., alongside the original 18 packages tested for the April, 2004 issue.

Go directly to the review home page

For the past 18 years, Berger has conducted detailed reviews of a wide cross-section of the computerized maintenance management system (CMMS) and enterprise asset management (EAM) packages available in North America. Many vendors have come and gone, merged and been acquired, as well as continuously improved their product offerings in response to changing user demands. Breakthroughs in hardware, software and telecommunications technology have also played a significant role in driving change.

The results now available at www.plantservices.com were derived by inviting 70 CMMS vendors to complete a 10-page survey defining in detail the degrees of functionality of their packages in some 300 categories. Those that are included in the comparison were required to demonstrate their performance in each category under Berger’s watchful eyes.

The half-day, in-person reviews ensured consistent interpretation of each survey question and that the same criteria were applied to every vendor. Responses that could not be audited (number of sites, pricing, annual sales, etc.) were examined by Berger for reasonability in the context of his considerable experience.

In the many cases, vendors self-evaluations did not align with Berger’s criteria, and he corrected the survey responses before we added them to the comparison.

Plant Services welcomes participation by any and all CMMS/EAM suppliers that are willing to undergo the rigorous review process, and will continue to add to and update the comparison table with additional vendors and new versions of existing packages


Vendors grilled by Berger

 Supplier   Package
 Assetpoint  Tabware 5.1
 Cybermetrics  FaciliWorks 6
 Datastream Systems  Datastream 7i 7.6
 DPSI  iMaint 2.31
 eXegeSys  eXegeSys Asset Maintenance 6.5
 fsc limited  4Site 4.0
 IFS North America  IFS Applications 2003
 Indus Intl.  InSite EE 4.0
 Invensys  Advantis 4.0
 Ivara  Ivara 4.0
 Maintenance Connection  Maintenance Connection
 MicroWest Software Systems  AMMS 10
 MRO Software  Maximo 5.2
 OpWare  ProTex Plus 7.134
 Oracle  Oracle Enterprise Asset Management 11i9
 PeopleSoft  EnterpriseOne Capital Asset Management 8.10
 Revere  Immpower R6
 SAP  mySAP Business Suite and R/3 4.7
 Synergen  Synergen 6
 Thinkage Ltd.  MainBoss CMMS 2.9


Paul Studebaker is editor in chief of Plant Services magazine.

Show Comments
Hide Comments

Join the discussion

We welcome your thoughtful comments.
All comments will display your user name.

Want to participate in the discussion?

Register for free

Log in for complete access.

Comments

No one has commented on this page yet.

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments