CMMS Review Sections

Jump to Questions and link for:

Questions  1 - 11:  Company - Package - Price

Questions 12 - 20: Integration

Questions 21 - 35: Basic Capabilities

Questions 36 - 43: Work Order Scheduling

Questions 44 - 51: Work Order Control

Questions 52 - 67: Inventory Control & Purchasing

Questions 68 - 73: Preventive and Condition-Based Maintenance I

Questions 74 - 82: Preventive and Condition-Based Maintenance II

Questions 83 - 91:
Equipment History

Questions 92 - 94: Advanced Functions & Displays I

Questions 95 - 100: Advanced Functions & Displays II

 
#1 Open Questions 1 - 11:  Company - Package - Price
#2 Open Questions 12 - 20: Integration
11 Language: In what language is the program written?
12a Cost % hardware: What percent of the total invoice to a new customer is for hardware?
12b Cost % software: What percent of the total invoice to a new customer is for software licenses?
12c Cost % customization: What percent of the total invoice to a new customer is for customization?
12d Cost % business redesign: What percent of the total invoice to a new customer is for business process redesign?
12e Cost % implementation: What percent of the total invoice to a new customer is for implementation?
13a Implementations targeting KPIs: Prior to implementation, in what percent of installations are targets set for improvement of key performance measures?
13b 1-5   KPIs: The top five key measures. 
14a % cost savings: The average cost savings achieved per site after implementing the CMMS.
14b % revenue increase: The average revenue enhancement achieved per site after implementing the CMMS
15a % Shared fee: The percentage of customers where normal fee is conditional on meeting performance targets for the customers' operations, e.g., a penalty if a percent reduction in downtime is not achieved)
15b % Shared rewards: The percentage of customers where a bonus is available upon achieving performance hurdles

15c

% No incentive: The percentage of customers where there is no formal linkage between cost and results
16 Tracking: Is each user company's customer satisfaction/loyalty tracked with a survey that is comprehensive (i.e., high percent of customer base, across multiple users per company, for many measures, more than once per company)?
17a Third-party ERP: Does the vendor have specialized software for integrating third-party ERP software?
17b Third-party CAD: Does the vendor have specialized software for integrating third-party CAD software?
17c Third-party PdM: Does the vendor have specialized software for integrating third-party PdM software (e.g. vibration, lubrication, thermography)?
17d Third-party data: Does the vendor have specialized software for integrating third-party shop-floor data collection systems (e.g. HMI, PLC, SCADA)?
17e Third-party handheld? Does the vendor have specialized software for integrating third-party wireless handhelds (e.g. PDAs, barcode readers)?
17f Other integration: Other third-party software integration capabilities?
18 Phase-in: Can clients use a phased approach to implement the CMMS, buying greater functionality over time?
19 Remote database synch: Does the CMMS have built-in utilities to allow remote user sites to synchronize databases?

20

Top

Browser/look & feel: Does the browser version have the same functionality and a similar look and feel to the client/server CMMS package?

 

#3 Open Questions 21 - 35: Basic Capabilities
21 Voice: Can information be received and transmitted remotely via an interactive voice response (IVR) system?
22a Format error-check: Is there error-checking capability for format (e.g., part number must be five numeric digits starting with an alpha character)?
22b Range error-check: Is there error-checking capability for range (e.g., equipment code ranges from 1500 to 3000)?
22c Logic error-check: Is there error-checking capability for logic (e.g., wrong engine on vehicle, too many or not enough pumps in a given piece of equipment)?
23 Error message quality: Are error or other messages comprehensive, easy to understand and suggest solutions?
24 Custom error messages: Are error, warning and other messages customizable by the user?

25

User-defined defaults: Can the user define all default values to ease data entry?
26a Multi-language log-on: Does the package support multiple languages in one implementation such that you can tailor each user screen to a given language based on logon?
26b Multi-language toggle: Can each user toggle between two or more languages at a given terminal?
27 Quick data entry: Is there a quick data-entry screen for high-volume entries, such as system startup or a dispatch desk?
28 Online help: Is there online help specific to procedures (i.e., "how-to" help)?
29 Help examples: Are examples given throughout help screens?
30 Help tailoring: Is online help tailored to the knowledge and experience of the user?
31a Training days, supervisor: How many days of classroom/CBT training would you recommend for the average novice maintenance supervisor to take for your CMMS?
31b Training days, planner: How much classroom/CBT training would you recommend for the average novice maintenance planner to take for your CMMS?
31c Training days, tradesperson: How much classroom/CBT training would you recommend for the average novice maintenance tradesperson to take for your CMMS?
31d Training days, buyer: How much classroom/CBT training would you recommend for the average novice buyer to take for your CMMS?
32 Custom business rules: Are embedded business rules easily customizable by the user (e.g., approval limits and routing)?
33 Workflow integration: Is workflow software fully integrated into the CMMS?
34 Drill-down: Is there drill-down capability for summary reports and listings?

35

Top

Editing: Can you edit data while viewing in spreadsheet or list mode (e.g., outstanding work orders)?

 

#4 Open Questions 36 - 43: Work Order Scheduling
36 Work order hierarchy: Is there a hierarchy of work orders where each level can be scheduled separately?

37

Blanket work orders: Can you create blanket work orders for planning/recording work, including recording blanket WO #, as well as equipment number and/or cost center (e.g., to avoid issuing a work order for jobs under 30 minutes)?
38a Time-based priorities: The number of time-based priority fields
38b Criticality priorities: The number of equipment criticality-based priority fields
38c Health & safety priorities: The number of health and safety-based priority fields
38d Other priorities/levels: Other priority fields/number of levels
38e User-defined priorities: The number of user-defined priority fields
39 Multiple priorities: Are priorities combined and used to determine or suggest a schedule (e.g., multiply priorities together)?
40 Schedule display: Can the schedule display in-process work orders, including revised hours by craft to completion or percent completion?
41 Graphical scheduling: Can you drag and drop work orders and/or available resources on a graphical schedule, and see the effects on planned workload vs. capacity as well as resultant availability?
42 Schedule drill-down: Can you drill down to access work order information from within the schedule chart/graph?
43a What-if scheduling, priority-based: Can you perform "what-if" analysis on the schedule (i.e., go into simulation mode with an opportunity to accept or reject results of the simulation) using changes to work order priority?
43b What-if scheduling, duration-based: Can you perform "what-if" analysis on the schedule using changes to estimated duration?

43c

Top

What-if scheduling, labor-based: Can you perform "what-if" analysis on the schedule using changes to labor availability?

 

#5 Open Questions 44 - 51: Work Order Control
44a Resource scheduling: Can resources such as tools, cranes, or special equipment be scheduled separately (e.g., to avoid double booking)?
44b Resource analysis: Can resources such as tools, cranes, or special equipment be analyzed separately (e.g., utilization)?
44c Resource costing: Can resources such as tools, cranes, or special equipment be costed separately (e.g., using allocation by resource type)?

45

Part source identification: On a work order, can users easily select new, reconditioned or used parts?
46 Approval change on overrun: Does approval level change when a work order is overrun for total labor and material dollars booked?
47 Approval status change definition: Can you define approvals for status changes for work orders, purchase orders, etc.?
48 Cost center security: Can you prohibit a user charging dollars to someone else's cost center?
49 Contract tracking: Can you track contract maintenance?
50a Third-party billing, invoice: Can the system handle third-party billing (i.e., chargebacks), including creation of a third-party invoice for labor/materials?
50b Third-party billing, mark up L&M: Can the system handle third-party billing (i.e., chargebacks), including mark up of labor and material costs?
50c Third-party billing, mark up other: Can the system handle third-party billing (i.e., chargebacks), including mark up of costs other than labor/materials?
50d Third-party billing, rounding: Can the system handle third-party billing (i.e., chargebacks), including rounding of time and costs?
50e Third-party billing, minimum time: Can the system handle third-party billing (i.e., chargebacks), including establishing a minimum labor time?
50f Third-party billing, minimum charge: Can the system handle third-party billing (i.e., chargebacks), including establishing a minimum dollar charge?
50g Third-party billing security: Can the system handle third-party billing (i.e., chargebacks), including allowing customer to access only its own information?
51a Warranty work orders: Can the system perform summary reporting of all work orders on warranty?
51b Warranty claims: Can the system prepare warranty claims?
51c Multiple warranties: Can the system record and track multiple warranties per asset?
51d Warranty types: Can the system record warranty types (e.g., manufacturer, vendor, extended)?
51e Calendar warranties: Can the system track calendar-based warranties?
51f Meter warranties: Can the system track meter-based warranties, including start/expiration/threshold readings?
51g Warranty renewals: Can the system handle warranty renewals?
51h Serial-based warranty expiration: Can the system favor serialized parts closer to warranty expiration?

51i

Top

Non-serial-based warranty expiration: Can the system favor non-serialized parts closer to expiration?

 

#6 Open Questions 52 - 67: Inventory Control & Purchasing
52a LIFO inventory: Is LIFO available for the inventory module?
52b FIFO inventory: Is FIFO available for the inventory module?
52c Average costing: Is average costing available for the inventory module?
52d Standard costing: Is standard costing available for the inventory module?
53 Activity-based costing: Is activity-based-costing (ABC) fully integrated into the CMMS?
54 EOQ: Is economic order quantity (EOQ) calculated?
55a ABC analysis: Is ABC analysis done (i.e., categories for parts usage)?
55b XYZ analysis: Is XYZ analysis done (i.e., categories for parts value)?
56 Reorder smoothing: Does the reorder point have smoothing capability?
57a Service levels by part: Are service levels analyzed by part?
57b Service levels by category: Are service levels analyzed by part category?
58 What-if on service levels: Can you do "what-if" analysis on service levels to determine resultant inventory values?
59 Cycle counts: Will the CMMS program assist in determining cycle counts?
60 Supplier history: Can you track supplier history?
61 Supplier rating: Can you rate suppliers?
62 E-procurement: Can the system handle e-procurement (e.g., catalog, purchase orders, quotations, and vendor invoices)?
63a History-based reorder: Is usage history automatically checked to suggest corrections to reorder points?
63b History-based reorder: Is usage history automatically checked to suggest corrections to reorder points?
63c Max level-based reorder: Is maximum level history automatically checked to suggest corrections to reorder points?
64 Component tracking: Can components be serialized and repair history/costs tracked (i.e. from receipt to installation, to vendor repair, to receipt upon return, to costing at repaired, depreciated or appreciated value, to new parent equipment)?

65

New/used parts: When booking parts required for a work order, will the parts on-hand listing within the work order screen show repaired or used parts/components available separately from new ones?
66a Expected delivery: Will the purchase order accommodate expected delivery date for each line item?
66b Multiple account codes: Will the purchase order accommodate multiple account codes for each line item?
66c Status code: Will the purchase order accommodate a status code for each line item?
66d Multiple ship-to: Will the purchase order accommodate multiple ship-to locations for each line item?
66e Tax codes: Will the purchase order accommodate tax codes for each line item?
66f Receipt acknowledgement: Will the purchase order accommodate receiving acknowledgement for each line item?

67

Top

Consignments: Does the system handle consignments?

 

#7 Open Questions 68 - 73: Preventive and Condition-Based Maintenance I
68a Standard PM tasks: Is standard data available for PM task definitions?
68b Standard PM task times: Is standard data available for PM task times?
68c Standard corrective tasks: Is standard data available for corrective tasks?
68d Standard RCM conditions: Is standard data available for RCM conditions linked to tasks?
68e Standard safety: Is standard data available for safety checklists and tasks?
69 PM triggers: Can you trigger PM by time, usage and event?
70a Multiple condition triggers: Can you trigger preventive maintenance by multiple condition indicators per asset?
70b Automatic trigger reset: Does a trigger from one condition-based indicator reset all other triggers for a given asset?
70c Nested triggers: Can you nest triggers with different cycles?
70d Combined indicators: Can you combine indicators using Boolean logic to create consolidated or alternate triggers?
70e Recommend corrective action: Can you recommend corrective action based on condition, i.e., using indicators, Boolean logic, and/or setpoints (e.g., oil analysis reveals gas, particulate or temperature trends that necessitate a given PM work request)?
70f Preferred date: Can you trigger a PM routine on a preferred day or date if within tolerance?
70g Forecast rounds schedule: Can you forecast when the next meter reading should occur based on historical readings?
70h PM shadowing: Can you do PM shadowing to avoid duplicate PMs?

70i

PM override: Can PMs be overridden or credit taken for corrective work that covers PM work due, to avoid duplication?
70j Reading validation: Can PM readings be validated with a user-defined validation formula?
70k Color-coded alarms: Can indicator/alarm tables be color-coded?
70l Component/indicator hierarchy: Can you create a graphic showing component hierarchy and corresponding indicators
70m Indicator drill-down: Can you have hot spots on the graphic for drill down to detail on indicators?
70n Graphic highlights: Are conditions and alarms visibly distinguished on the graphic (e.g., blinking, color change)?
70o Alarm acknowledge: Can you acknowledging alarms or conditions easily from within the graphic screen?
70p New condition entry: Can a new condition be easily entered from within the graphic screen?
71 History-based PM: Is PM history used to correct future PM scheduling?
72 Seasonal PM: Can users adjust the PM schedule for seasonality?

73

Top

Shutdowns/peaks/holidays: Does the PM schedule display shutdowns, peak production periods and/or holidays?

 

#8 Open Questions 74 - 82: Preventive and Condition-Based Maintenance II
74a PM by the hour: Can you schedule PM by the hour?
74b PM by recurrences: Can you schedule PM by recurrences?
74c PM by calendar: Can you schedule PM by recurring month, weeks or days?
74d PM by date: Can you specify PM by specific calendar dates?
74e PM by exception: Can you specify PM with specific calendar dates as exceptions?
75a PM route by asset type: Can you set up a PM route for a single asset type across multiple locations (e.g., inspection of all fire extinguishers in multiple buildings)?

75b

PM route by location: Can you set up a PM route for multiple assets in a single location (e.g., inspection of multiple assets on one stretch of roadway)?
76 GIS location: Can you inventory assets, route PMs and report on work history referencing a GIS locator?
77 Problem/cause/action: Can problem, cause and action taken be recorded against individual assets along the route (e.g., one fire extinguisher refilled, another required repair)?
78a L&M by asset: Can labor and material be charged to an individual asset along the route?
78b L&M averaged: Can labor and materials be charged using an average cost spread over all assets on the route?
79 Critical percent: Can you identify a "critical percent" for each asset/procedure (where 0% = PM just done, 100% = PM just due, 200% = PM not done after one complete cycle, etc.)?
80 Critical route: Can you generate a route based on Boolean logic surrounding the critical percent?
81 Auto priority increase: Will the priority automatically increase if PM is not done?
82a Multiple inspections: Do you have features and functions for inspection and risk assessment including multiple inspections at multiple points on an asset/infrastructure?
82b Risk/criticality record: Does inspection and risk assessment support recording results of a risk-based assessment defining risk and criticality of failure?
82c Automatic frequency: Does inspection and risk assessment support automatically increasing the frequency of inspection if the risk increases?
82d Confidence rating: Does inspection and risk assessment support the ability to define a "confidence rating" on the risk?
82e Expected value: Does inspection and risk assessment support providing the inspector with nominal (i.e., expected) values for a given inspection?
82f Historical information: Does inspection and risk assessment support providing the inspector with historical information including last value, date and description?
82g Track inspection tools: Does inspection and risk assessment support tracking replacement frequency for inspection tools?
82h Critical value formula: Does inspection and risk assessment support defining a formula to determine the critical value for inspection readings?
82i WO/PM on critical value: Does inspection and risk assessment support automatically issuing a standard work order or PM procedure if the critical value is reached?
82j Min/max values: Does inspection and risk assessment support defining min and max threshold values for inspection readings?
82k Tolerance: Does inspection and risk assessment support defining a tolerance percent?
82l Regression analysis: Does inspection and risk assessment support using regression analysis to predict the next date for reaching the critical value?

82m

Top

Extreme value: Does inspection and risk assessment support recording an "extreme value" (i.e., amount which cannot be exceeded)?

 

#9 Open Questions 83 - 91: Equipment History
83 Downtime vs. breakdown: Is production downtime distinguished from equipment breakdown, and are both tracked?
84 Actual vs. budget: Can you budget and track actual maintenance costs against budget?
85 Budget integration: Is the budgeting module directly integrated with the planned hours and planned material usage on the work orders?
86 Budget what-if: Can you perform "what-if" analysis on the budget by generating work orders or preparing a work plan in simulation mode, with an opportunity to accept or reject results of the simulation?
87 User-defined costs: Can you track equipment costs by user-defined statistics (e.g., cost per ton produced, cost per mile)?
88 Problem/cause/action: Are problem, cause and action codes grouped, nested and hierarchical?
89a Complaint analysis: Does the CMMS analyze, not just report on, relative frequencies and probabilities of complaints (i.e., using Pareto analysis, predictive trending, root cause analysis, correlation, forecasting, etc.)?
89b Root cause analysis: Does the CMMS analyze root causes?
89c Actions taken analysis: Does the CMMS analyze actions taken?
89d Idle/delay analysis: Does the CMMS analyze idle or delay time?
89e WO history analysis: Does the CMMS analyze work order status history?
89f Availability analysis: Does the CMMS analyze asset availability?
89g Utilization analysis: Does the CMMS analyze asset utilization (i.e. available and used)?
89h Performance analysis: Does the CMMS analyze asset performance (e.g. speed)?
89i Quality impact: Does the CMMS analyze product quality impact (e.g. asset causing rework, etc.)?
90a Report MTBF: Does the CMMS report on mean time between failures?
90b MTBF by root cause: Does the CMMS report on MTBF for a specific root cause?
90c Report MTTR: Does the CMMS report on mean time to repair?
90d Report MWT: Does the CMMS report on mean wait time (MWT) or response time?
90e TSLF by problem: Does the CMMS report time since last failure trend for any problem code?
90f TSLF by cause: Does the CMMS report time since last failure (TSLF) trend for any cause code?
90g TSLF by action: Does the CMMS report time since last failure (TSLF) trend for any action code?
90h TSLF by checkpoint: Does the CMMS report time since last failure trend from the last checkpoint?

90i

Life cycle costing: Does the CMMS report lifecycle cost for a given asset or group of assets?

91

Top

Troubleshooting database: Is there a troubleshooting database to assist in diagnosing equipment repair problems?

 

#10 Open Questions 92 - 94: Advanced Functions & Displays I
92a Trigger on PM: Can you trigger a user-defined activity (such as an alarm, pager, email, or work order activation) when PM inspection measures exceed control limits?
92b Trigger on limits: Can you trigger a user-defined activity when measures trend within a certain percentage of control limits?
92c Trigger on downtime: Can you trigger a user-defined activity when equipment downtime exceeds a threshold value?
92d Trigger on MTBF: Can you trigger a user-defined activity when average MTBF is outside a given range of values?
92e Trigger on warranty: Can you trigger a user-defined activity when equipment or a component is due for warranty work?
92f Trigger on parts missing: Can you trigger a user-defined activity when parts have not arrived for a work order coming due?
92g Trigger on wait time: Can you trigger a user-defined activity when wait time within a workflow exceeds a value?
92h Trigger on activity times: Can you trigger a user-defined activity when activity times within a workflow exceed standard?
92i Trigger on PM critical %: Can you trigger a user-defined activity when a PM critical percent has exceeded a user-defined threshold?
92j Trigger on expenditure: Can you trigger a user-defined activity when the rate of expenditure will cause a budget overrun?
92k Trigger on repeat failure: Can you trigger a user-defined activity when a failure has repeated within a user-defined period?
93a Lookup equipment: Is there an MS Windows Explorer-style lookup capability for the hierarchy of equipment?
93b Lookup parts: Is there an MS Windows Explorer-style lookup capability for parts?
93c Lookup suppliers: Is there an MS Windows Explorer-style lookup capability for suppliers?
93d Lookup employees: Is there an MS Windows Explorer-style lookup capability for employees?
93e Lookup work orders: Is there an MS Windows Explorer-style lookup capability for work orders?
93f Lookup online help: Is there an MS Windows Explorer-style lookup capability for online help?
93g Lookup corporate structure: Is there an MS Windows Explorer-style lookup capability for corporate structure?
93h Lookup warehouses/stores: Is there an MS Windows Explorer-style lookup capability for warehouses/stores?
93i Lookup projects: Is there an MS Windows Explorer-style lookup capability for projects?
93j Lookup KPIs: Is there an MS Windows Explorer-style lookup capability for key performance indicators (KPIs)?
93k Lookup menus/functions: Is there an MS Windows Explorer-style lookup capability for the CMMS menus/functions?

93l

Lookup G/L accounts: Is there an MS Windows Explorer-style lookup capability for general ledger accounts?

94

Top

Toggle: For each of the hierarchies in question 93, can you toggle between multiple windows showing additional information?

 

#11 Open Questions 95 - 100: Advanced Functions & Displays II
95a Business intelligence: Are business intelligence reporting formats such as dashboards, stoplights, etc., fully integrated?
95b Balanced scorecard: Are balanced scorecard reporting formats fully integrated?
95c KPI reports: Are key performance indicator and target reporting formats fully integrated?
96a PDA WO integration: Does the CMMS interface seamlessly with PDAs including ability to download work orders to the PDA?
96b PDA work: Does the CMMS interface seamlessly with PDAs including ability to upload hours worked and work done from the PDA?
96c PDA parts required: Does the CMMS interface seamlessly with PDAs including ability to download parts required to the PDA?
96d PDA inventory: Does the CMMS interface seamlessly with PDAs including ability to download other inventory information to the PDA?
96e PDA parts used: Does the CMMS interface seamlessly with PDAs including ability to upload parts used?
96f PDA tools required: Does the CMMS interface seamlessly with PDAs including ability to download tools required to the PDA?
96g PDA scanner: Does the CMMS interface seamlessly with PDAs including ability to use a built-in scanner for barcodes on assets/parts/badges?
96h PDA work requests: Does the CMMS interface seamlessly with PDAs including ability to enter and upload work requests?
97a Fleet VMRS: Do vehicle/fleet maintenance functions include built-in VMRS standard codes?
97b Fleet fuel: Do vehicle/fleet maintenance functions include consumption rate of fuel and other consumables?
97c Vehicle mileage: Do vehicle/fleet maintenance functions include vehicle mileage?
97d Vehicle utilization: Do vehicle/fleet maintenance functions include vehicle utilization?
97e Vehicle status: Do vehicle/fleet maintenance functions include real-time operational status of a given vehicle?
97f Vehicle environment: Do vehicle/fleet maintenance functions include analysis of environmental correlations such as weather?
97g Vehicle wear analysis: Do vehicle/fleet maintenance functions include wear measure history and analysis on tires, brakes, etc.?
97h Vehicle reservations: Do vehicle/fleet maintenance functions include vehicle reservations?
97i Fleet depreciation: Do vehicle/fleet maintenance functions include depreciation of fleet assets?
97j Vehicle operation: Do vehicle/fleet maintenance functions include recording operational data for a given vehicle (e.g. primary driver, key number)?
98 IT asset management: Are there features and functions specific to technology asset management?
99 Capital asset planning: Are there features and functions specific to capital asset planning?
100a Tool management: Is there is a separate, comprehensive, specialized tool management module?
100b Keys management: Is there is a separate, comprehensive, specialized keys management module?

100c

Top

Lockout/tagout: Is there is a separate, comprehensive, specialized lockout/tagout tool management module?
Show Comments
Hide Comments

Join the discussion

We welcome your thoughtful comments.
All comments will display your user name.

Want to participate in the discussion?

Register for free

Log in for complete access.

Comments

No one has commented on this page yet.

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments